Too many cooks, too many managers

Since we are still hiring and going through the interview process, a disappointing trend has emerged. When asked of their future plans, and where they see themselves, people with very little experience make the claim they want to be a "lead" or manager within a year.

They don't speak of going deep and being proficient in the role they're interviewing for. There is no mention of being the go-to person for help and information. No mention of being a subject matter expert. Taking this job is merely a stepping stone. After checking off a couple boxes on their mental to-do list they will take on bigger and better. Never mind they only have two years of experience in this field.

It's pretty clear their desire is to pretend to be in charge and tell other people what to do, not produce great results they can be proud of and others might emulate. I don't want to work with people like that.

There is nothing wrong with aspiring to take on a leadership role, but it's more than just telling people what to do or thinking you have organizational skills. "My desk is tidy, I can be a manager." "I attend meetings on time, I can be a manager."

I'm not a manager, and have no interest in being one, or a PM, or a Lead, or a insert grand Poobah title here. I've been around for awhile and over my career, I've had some absolutely terrible managers and I've had some horrific product managers, including a PM that finally left earlier this year.

Even now, we have bouts where people take up the mantle of manager and make an absolute mess of things. Their lack of depth and understanding led to multiple missed deadlines. Their total lack of experience made them unable to adjust to changing conditions, time constraints and customer demand. This lead to a lot of team frustration, which ultimately sent a handful of people looking for employment elsewhere.

Before taking up the mantle of being a manager or even a lead, be a pillar of support to the person your current manager and team. If they need help, give it. If they have questions, answer them. If the project is going off the rails and chaos begins to ensue, be the calm voice of reason. Or at the very least, don't get swept up in it. If that's not happening, not management material.

In addition, go deep within your current project, discipline, or area of expertise. Understand what your company wants from a project. Understand what the customer wants. Understand what makes a good UI. Anticipate what features may help them. Know what it takes to stand up a database and the challenges people face. Learn the customer business so you can anticipate problems, offer suggestions and be aware of potential hazards.

Just as importantly, know the people. Understand how they work. Understand what they need to be effective. What are they good at? What are they not so good at? It's more than just strengths and weaknesses. If they're not effective, you won't be.

Even above that, be the perfect manager of yourself. Meet deadlines. Be efficient. Be productive (not just busy). Create methods and process others want to emulate.

We have multiple examples on two specific projects, where there is chaos and disorder because everyone feels they are in charge, which means no one is in charge. There are arguments over how things should be done, people want their process and agenda to be the one that other follow, they don't support each other, they go around each other to get their "priority feature" implemented first.

Even simple things can't be done correctly. During the standup the question is asked, "Does anyone have an update?" That's totally incorrect. Right from the start people are interrupting each other, talking over each other, and there is no sense of leadership. Immediately they're frustrated.

Call on people directly. Establish order and method. "Joe, can you give us your update?"

Another example: we had a QA engineer who got the help of two temporary resources to cover an End of Year process for the customer. Instead of giving them all the information they would need to test, get everyone up to speed, and make the project a grand success, he chose this opportunity to exert himself as a "manager" and held court on how to be an effective QA engineer. Or more specifically, what he thought it took. He's no longer with the company.

But unfortunately, that mentality is quite common.

In the recent past, I've had conversations with managers and project managers that where in effect, "What do I need to do to make you successful? We can either work together and produce great results, or we can work against each and produce some serious crap."

I don't have the answers on how to be a good manager. It's more that I've observed far too many people jumping to the head of the line with ambitions of being a manger, way before they are ready. They have no career capital. They have no depth to their knowledge. They have no previous successes to their name. Yet, they state and feel they should be in charge and have what it takes to manage.

What they don't realize is that there is a massive difference between managing, and leading.

Other articles of interest:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Comments
  • How To Disable the Quicken Registration Prompt (32)
    • Mike: Hi, for anyone still trying to run older versions of Quicken, mine is 2004, I hope this helps. I managed to get it running on my old laptop by adding the three missing dll files, when I needed to upgrade I thought I would be able...
    • Juani: Hi, I have a registered Quicken 2016 and now my files are being held hostage by Intuit, cannot log in with my ID unless I upgrade therefore buy a subscription, I need to access my files, please HELP. Thanks
    • David: A BIG Thank you! I regularly reinstall Windows OS’s using different hardware configs. In short, Quicken 2011 (it’s March of 2020 as I write this) has been a program I’ve been very happy with and continue to use....
    • Karen L: Today I rang Reckon Australia again, got a different guy and he talked me through the process of getting me a new product key to enter since I already had the licence and it had been extended. Reckon have only extended it by 1...
    • Karen L: I have Australian Quicken 2008 on Windows 8.1. It keeps asking me to renew my licence which Reckon did for me however the activation won’t work. I tried this to disable the registration prompt however it did not stop the...
  • Enter dates into a date picker for Chrome and Firefox (1)
    • Prasanna: Hello, How to enter a previous month FIRST day and LAST day from the system date. Thanks Prasanna
  • Building Relationships with Developers (1)
    • Carlos Herrera: Ah yes. I have a team of software developers and it is genuinely so hard to keep them in the loop during projects. Though the more we work the better the communication becomes and we go from a trail and error process to a...
  • Integrating DevonAgent Pro with Alfred (1)
    • J. Garr: Beautiful, sweet, and simple. I love it; thanks for posting this solution.
  • Round and Round with the For..Next in Katalon Studio (1)
    • Sweet Ophaline Labador: Hello can you help me how to loop this scenario. Checking the elements is just the same. I want to check that the following function is available in Track Shipment – clicking on this can...
  • Parsing Strings in Katalon – Split, Substring and Readlines (6)
    • Don Pedro: String tempText=”Date Month January. Revenue $1,355,721.00″ println(tempText.split(“ \$”)[1]) You need to escape the $ with \$ The [1] on the split captures characters on the right of the split [0]...
    • Prasad: Hi, I need to get the substring from the below string ‘Date Month January. Revenue $1,355,721.00’ I want to extract text after $ value. Please help Thank you
  • Working with Dates and Date Formatting in Katalon Studio (15)
    • Sangeethaa: How to get previous day’s date(Yesterday’s date)? Actually I was using today.previous() before,it was working fine till today morning.Now its not retrieving right date. Can anyone please guide me on this.
    • Don Pedro: That could be a little tricky. First, is the text/format always going to be the same? You will need to do some parsing. Separate the first but of text at 2019. After that, split the text again to get rid of Central Standard...
  • Output status messages and test information by writing to the Log File Viewer in Katalon Studio (6)
    • Saranya: Good One. Could you plz share link to access all your katalon related blogs. ThankQ
    • Rodrigo Calabretta: I’m using the KeywordUtil.markFailed or KeywordUtil.markError and my test stops is being shown as Error and If I use in the @afterTestCase the testCaseContext.getTestCaseSta tus() to show the status test case...